News
  • Login
  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Worklife
  • Travel
  • Reel
  • Future
  • More
Monday, May 12, 2025
No Result
View All Result

NEWS

3 °c
London
8 ° Wed
9 ° Thu
11 ° Fri
13 ° Sat
  • Home
  • Video
  • World
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • US & Canada

    Three things to know about the Australian election result

    Three men held over suitcases stuffed with hermit crabs

    Miss World Africa beauty queen and Botswana’s youngest cabinet minister

    India-Pakistan ceasefire appears to hold after accusations of violations

    Crowds cheer as Pope holds first Sunday address

    Peru kidnapping leaves 13 dead in gold mine

    Israeli embassy in London was suspected terror plot target

    The countries are finally talking but why now?

    How Peter Dutton lost his heartland

  • UK
    • All
    • England
    • N. Ireland
    • Politics
    • Scotland
    • Wales

    Second arrest over MSC Virtuosa cruise ship death

    ‘I can’t play a festival that’s £800 a ticket’

    Life or death decisions as politicians weigh up assisted dying vote

    Young people in care critical of support available

    Second teenager dies after swimming incident

    Time to end care worker recruitment from abroad, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper says

    Man charged with Manor House murder and robbery of 87-year-old

    Sisters call for alarms in cars

    Exam revision disrupted as cyber attackers target Edinburgh council

  • Business
    • All
    • Companies
    • Connected World
    • Economy
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Global Trade
    • Technology of Business

    Filmmakers in Soho voice concerns on President Trump film tariffs

    Barnsley Council to consider £4m household support fund

    The Hollywood films made in the UK

    ‘I freaked out and spent $400 online’

    Inside the secretive world of the fashion brand

    UK must ‘do everything’ to rebuild trade with EU

    Trump hints tariffs on China may drop as talks set to begin

    How quickly are prices rising?

    UK interest rates cut to 4.25% by Bank of England

  • Tech
  • Entertainment & Arts

    Dancers say Lizzo ‘needs to be held accountable’ over harassment claims

    Freddie Mercury: Contents of former home being sold at auction

    Harry Potter and the Cursed Child marks seven years in West End

    Sinéad O’Connor: In her own words

    Tom Jones: Neighbour surprised to find singer in flat below

    BBC presenter: What is the evidence?

    Watch: The latest on BBC presenter story… in under a minute

    Watch: George Alagiah’s extraordinary career

    BBC News presenter pays tribute to ‘much loved’ colleague George Alagiah

    Excited filmgoers: 'Barbie is everything'

  • Science
  • Health
  • In Pictures
  • Reality Check
  • Have your say
  • More
    • Newsbeat
    • Long Reads

NEWS

No Result
View All Result
Home UK Scotland

Life or death decisions as politicians weigh up assisted dying vote

May 11, 2025
in Scotland
8 min read
245 7
0
491
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Glenn Campbell

BBC Scotland political editor

Getty Images Liam McArthur at the launch of his bill in March 2024. He is standing behind a podium and in front of a blue background with the words 78% of Scots support assisted dying.Getty Images

Liam McArthur launched his bill in March 2024

There are few decisions Holyrood can take that are bigger than a vote on assisted dying.

Whether or not to allow terminally ill adults to seek medical help to end their lives is of fundamental consequence.

The vote on Tuesday will also be of note to decision makers at Westminster, where similar proposals for England and Wales are working their way through the UK parliament.

MSPs have twice before rejected attempts to change the law, most recently in 2015.

The Liberal Democrat MSP Liam McArthur, who has developed the current proposal, believes the mood in parliament is now “very, very different”.

He clearly expects his bill to have more support than previous attempts – but that is not the same as saying that he is sure it has sufficient support to proceed.

Speaking on BBC Scotland’s The Sunday Show, he said he expected the first vote to be “close”.

PA Media John Swinney standing on stage wearing a blue suit and a burgundy tie. There is a microphone to his right and there is a dark blue background.PA Media

John Swinney has consistently voted against assisted dying

He could be concerned in part about the potential impact of recent interventions.

First Minister John Swinney has not changed his position over the years.

He has consistently voted against assisted dying and it was no surprise when he revealed that he intends to do so again.

He said that representations in favour of assisted dying from constituents who have witnessed loved ones suffer terribly at the end of their lives caused him to agonise over his decision.

However, he believes that changing the law would unacceptably alter the relationship between doctors and their patients and that it could put pressure on sick and disabled people to end their lives prematurely.

Swinney has also been careful to stress that he has reached a personal view, that he is not seeking to influence others, and the Scottish government will remain “neutral”.

Having said that, the Scottish government has already advised that it thinks Holyrood would be exceeding its authority by voting for assisted dying because the law on lethal drugs is under Westminster control.

McArthur argues that these issues could be overcome if Holyrood votes in favour of assisted dying.

Each MSP is free to vote according to their conscience rather than along party lines.

That does not mean the views of party leaders are unimportant. They could well sway the opinion of undecided MSPs.

Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay is understood to be “sceptical” about the current bill.

And Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has said he will be voting against, while pressing for greater investment in palliative care.

The Scottish Green and Scottish Liberal Democrat leaders are expected to support the legislation.

Getty Images Campaigners gather outside Houses of Parliament to demonstrate their opposition to Kim Leadbeater MP's Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill in the House of Commons in November 2024.Getty Images

Campaigners held demonstrations ahead of the vote on the UK bill last November

The indications are that the vote on Tuesday could be relatively close. There appears to be a sufficient number of MSPs who have not declared their views to swing the decision either way.

Liam McArthur is still having conversations with undecided MSPs in the hope of winning them over.

He argues that not changing the law would let down too many Scots who suffer in the final stages of life to a degree that leaves their loved ones “traumatised”.

Some politicians are trying to weigh up the arguments over the weekend. Others intend to listen to the debate in parliament before making up their minds.

If there are more “no” votes than “yes” votes from MSPs on Tuesday the bill will be rejected.

If there are more “yes” votes than “no” votes that is not the last word on the issue.

Getty Images Campaigners gather in Parliament Square to demonstrate their support for assisted dying as Kim Leadbeater MP's bill in November 2024.Getty Images

The bill for England and Wales was backed by MPs in November

That would amount to approval in principle. The debate would continue with the potential for MSPs to make changes to the bill to ease concerns.

There would need to be another vote of the whole Scottish Parliament on any final version of the legislation.

The separate bill for England and Wales was backed by MPs in November, but has yet to go to a final vote in the Commons.

One MSP described the assisted dying decision in Scotland as an opportunity for Holyrood to be at its best.

Whatever the outcome, they hope for a heavyweight debate with powerful arguments on both sides and the careful consideration that sensitive matters of life and death demand.



Source link

Tags: assisteddeathdecisionsdyinglifepoliticiansvoteweigh

Related Posts

Exam revision disrupted as cyber attackers target Edinburgh council

May 10, 2025
0

Getty ImagesParents have been sent texts telling them that students' passwords have been reset as a precautionPupils in Edinburgh...

Patient safety commissioner for Scotland recruited

May 9, 2025
0

Scotland's first ever Patient Safety Commissioner is set to be appointed. Experienced healthcare executive Karen Titchener will take up...

John Swinney says he will not support assisted dying bill

May 8, 2025
0

Glenn CampbellBBC Scotland Political EditorBBCFirst Minister John Swinney has said he will not support a bill which would allow...

  • Ballyjamesduff: Man dies after hit-and-run in County Cavan

    510 shares
    Share 204 Tweet 128
  • Somalia: Rare access to its US-funded 'lightning commando brigade

    508 shares
    Share 203 Tweet 127
  • Uganda arrest over deadly New Year Freedom City mall crush

    507 shares
    Share 203 Tweet 127
  • George Weah: Hopes for Liberian football revival with legend as President

    506 shares
    Share 202 Tweet 127
  • Google faces new multi-billion advertising lawsuit

    506 shares
    Share 202 Tweet 127
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

Ballyjamesduff: Man dies after hit-and-run in County Cavan

August 19, 2022

Somalia: Rare access to its US-funded 'lightning commando brigade

November 23, 2022

Uganda arrest over deadly New Year Freedom City mall crush

January 3, 2023

Stranger Things actor Jamie Campbell Bower praised for addiction post

0

NHS to close Tavistock child gender identity clinic

0

Cold sores traced back to kissing in Bronze Age by Cambridge research

0

Second arrest over MSC Virtuosa cruise ship death

May 11, 2025

Filmmakers in Soho voice concerns on President Trump film tariffs

May 11, 2025

BBC Inside Science

May 11, 2025

Categories

England

Second arrest over MSC Virtuosa cruise ship death

May 11, 2025
0

A second man has been arrested after a 60-year-old man died following an altercation on a cruise ship.James Messham,...

Read more

Filmmakers in Soho voice concerns on President Trump film tariffs

May 11, 2025
News

Copyright © 2020 JBC News Powered by JOOJ.us

Explore the JBC

  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Worklife
  • Travel
  • Reel
  • Future
  • More

Follow Us

  • Home Main
  • Video
  • World
  • Top News
  • Business
  • Sport
  • Tech
  • UK
  • In Pictures
  • Health
  • Reality Check
  • Science
  • Entertainment & Arts
  • Login

Copyright © 2020 JBC News Powered by JOOJ.us

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
News
More Sites

    MORE

  • Home
  • News
  • Sport
  • Worklife
  • Travel
  • Reel
  • Future
  • More
  • News

    JBC News